Reviewing the reviews

As part of my role as liaison librarian, I am the shelving supervisor for the Social Sciences floor. Mostly the shelving ticks along nicely, but I am often involved in arranging cover for busy periods (like right now!). Another part of being shelving supervisor is delivering annual Staff Development Reviews (SDR) for our part-time shelvers. This year, I was responsible for two SDRs. This was the first time I have been in a supervisory role, and my first experience of a formal management responsibility. I was feeling quite nervous, but also fairly excited.

The university is very good at providing opportunities for personal and professional development, and to my great relief provides workshops for both new reviewees and new reviewers. Although I fell under both categories, I only attended the workshop for new reviewers, since there would be a significant overlap in content. I had expected this workshop to be full of management jargon, but in actuality it was incredibly helpful.

The presenter was knowledgeable and relatable. All my concerns and questions were addressed, and I came out of it much more confident and relaxed about delivering my two SDRs. Some of the advice I found particularly useful (though not exhaustive), and things I learnt from the two SDRs included:

  • Block out time for writing up too – The SDRs took 30-45 minutes, but I blocked out an hour and a half of my time, so I could write up our discussion straight-away. It stops you forgetting things, but also I feel it demonstrates your commitment to their professional development.
  • They should be talking 70% of the time – ask open ended questions, which are far more conducive to discussion than yes/no answers. In my first SDR I found myself slipping in this regard, which leads me to…
  • Plan what you will talk about, and practice– that might feel a bit weird for a one-to-one discussion, but remember that the more prepared you are the better you’ll feel, and the better they’ll feel. There’s nothing worse than your manager rifling through papers trying to remind themselves what exactly it is you do!

In particular, I received some great advice about SDRs with staff who have been with the institution much longer than you have:

  • Frame it in light of changes – This was easy for me, as we are about to have some major rewiring and refurbishment, and had just undergone some significant book moves.
  • Might be related to objectives from your own SDR – we were advised to have our own SDRs before setting the agenda for theirs, as our own objectives may well feed into theirs.

Additionally, I found Simon Barron’s Idiots Guide to Annual Staff Reviews both helpful and comforting. The later comments about impostor syndrome were, too, very reassuring!

I am glad I did these SDRs, as it is very likely I will be in a job role in the future which also involves the supervision/management of staff and therefore carrying out annual reviews. Now I have done them, they are not nearly as scary as I had thought. Plus, it’s a useful addition to my Chartership portfolio.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s